| Platinum | Happy Joe's Pizza |
| Platinum | Nite Train Pizza |
| Gold | Planet Pizza |
| Gold | The Starving Rooster |
| Silver | Devils Fire |
| Silver | Sammy's Pizza Pasta & Chicken |
| Bronze | Uncle Maddio's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hot Stuff Pizza |
| Top Pick | Papa John's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rolling in Sugar |