| Platinum | Koselig: The Cozy Shop |
| Gold | The Purple Door |
| Silver | Barnes & Noble Booksellers |
| Bronze | Peggy's Gift Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Focused Beam Engraving & Gift Shop |
| Top Pick | Joan's Hallmark Shop |
| Top Pick | Spencer's |
| Top Pick | Spirits and Twigs |
| Top Pick | Tarts Gifts |
| Top Pick | Taube Museum of Art |