| Platinum | 1910 Bar & Grill |
| Gold | EbeneeZer's Eatery & Irish Pub |
| Silver | JL Beers |
| Silver | McDonald's |
| Bronze | Five Guys |
| Top Pick | Finishline Burgers and Brew |
| Top Pick | Homesteaders Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Ironhorse Kitchen and Bar |
| Top Pick | Magic City Hoagies |
| Top Pick | Rocky's Burgers, Franks & Fries |